Written by Melanie Kassel, Performance Editor
 |
Best Cotton
| CLICK HERE FOR PRICE |
 |
Best Fitted
| CLICK HERE FOR PRICE |
 |
Dryer Safe
| CLICK HERE FOR PRICE |
 |
Best Breathable
| CLICK HERE FOR PRICE |
 |
Best Polyester
| CLICK HERE FOR PRICE |
 |
Best Noiseless
| CLICK HERE FOR PRICE |
 |
Best Organic
| CLICK HERE FOR PRICE |
 |
Best Overall Value
| CLICK HERE FOR PRICE |
 |
Best Hypoallergenic
| CLICK HERE FOR PRICE |
9 Top-Rated Waterproof Crib Mattress Pads Review
SureGuard Mattress Protectors – Best Cotton
HIGHLIGHTS:
- Hypoallergenic
- Cotton
- Soft & Noiseless
- Durable & Easy to Clean
This soft cotton product is excellent in part because it’s made with a 100% cotton terry cloth surface, keeping your little one cozy throughout the night, and wicking away moisture. It’s free of PVC, vinyl, and toxic chemicals. Left with this peace of mind, you can doze easily knowing your baby is resting atop a safe product.
SafeGuard’s protectors are GREENGUARD certified, which means they are put to rigorous tests to meet high standards and minimize reactions due to asthma and allergies. GREENGUARD accredited products have gone through lengthy testing to carry this title, making them an easily trusted organization.
Additionally, this protector is noiseless, so you shouldn’t have to worry about your tot crunching around on a loud plastic cloth, potentially waking them in the middle of the night. The product is hypoallergenic and minimizes the possibility of your tot’s development becoming disrupted by allergic reactions.
American Baby Company – Best Fitted
HIGHLIGHTS:
- Soft Polyester
- Extra soft and quiet
- Easy to clean
This ultra-soft waterproof crib pad by American Baby Company offers an excellent snug fit, leaving your babe with a smooth, flat surface on which they can soundly snooze. This topper has extra-deep pockets, tightly fitting a standard 6″ crib without leaving any uncomfortable wrinkles or lumps.
This product is also remarkably quiet, eliminating crinkle noises and letting you and your munchkin sleep easily. Without the constant interruption of a baby mattress crinkling under your tot’s weight, you and your entire family may be able to get better rest.
The topper is easy to clean as well, letting you toss it into the wash as necessary, unlike other delicate products that need to be hand-washed. The top and bottom of the product is soft polyester, and the middle is where the waterproof layer hides, providing the utmost protection during those accident-prone nights.
Little One’s Pad – Dryer Safe
HIGHLIGHTS:
- Microfiber fabric top
- Ultra soft and quiet
- Easy to clean
This high-quality mattress pad is a cinch to clean and dry, as it won’t shrink in your dryer, letting you wash it again and again throughout your baby’s lifespan. It’s guaranteed to fit and specifically designed for a portable mini crib or mini Pack N Play, making it the ultimate buy for convenience.
Many pads for cribs today use cheaply made or thin threads to cut costs, making them fit poorly. However, the Little One’s Pad uses strong material that’s reinforced with quality fibers to fit appropriately time after time while retaining its snuggly soft exterior, even after hundreds of runs in the washing machine.
This pad is not only soft and durable, but it’s remarkably absorbent as well, soft on your tot’s sensitive skin but tough on leaks. The quilted microfiber topper soaks up liquids quickly and protects your baby’s mattress so it can last throughout their childhood.
Biloban – Best Ventilated
HIGHLIGHTS:
- Microfiber
- Ultra soft and quiet
- Easy to clean
This cozy waterproof pad combines ventilation with comfort and protects against unexpected leaks and spills while letting your babe snooze in peace. The waterproof cover is made of high-quality TPU material that’s machine washable for those unfortunate but inevitable accidents. Dense yet soft, the topper’s aerated holes let your munchkin snooze and breath with ease.
This waterproof crib mattress pad is created with food-grade TPU, which stands for Thermoplastic Polyurethane, it’s non-toxic, and is commonly known as the material that bridges rubbers and plastics.” The alloy is used in a wide variety of consumer goods.
This pad won’t make a crinkly noise as your baby adjusts throughout the night either, yet it’s thick enough to provide optimal comfort allowing for quality sleep. With the Biloban, your baby can rest soundly and breathe easily, letting your entire family get the slumber they need.
Carter’s – Best Polyester
HIGHLIGHTS:
- Polyester
- Easy to clean
Carter’s polyester mattress pad is a quality choice if you’re looking for something made of polyester. This material has various good qualities to benefit a family lifestyle when bringing up a small baby.
Polyester’s wrinkle resistance is also better than most other fabrics. It’s also great for regulating temperature, and has an excellent heat resistance and thermoplasticity, preventing your little one from becoming too warm in the night.
Additionally, it has remarkable strength to endure the trials of babyhood, and good elastic recovery, equipping this product to maintain its shape after countless washes. Polyester is an incredibly absorbent material as well, so when your little one has an accident, you can count on this pad to soak up any liquids quickly.
Many other mattress pads become easily stretched and worn out after repeated washings. However, polyester’s elasticity is similar to that of wool and can recover well when stretched.
Margaux & May – Best Noiseless
HIGHLIGHTS:
- Bamboo rayon fiber
- Plush and noiseless
- Easy to clean
Many waterproof crib mattress pads can create irritating crunching noises preventing your little one and you from getting a sound night of sleep. While this can be annoying, some families endure it because these noises are often due to the waterproof quality. However, you don’t have to let waterproof material be the end of your restful nights.
The Margaux & May waterproof crib pad is so soft and quiet you almost don’t even want to cover it with a sheet. Its additional padding gives it just enough give to provide a cozy soft environment, perfect for sleeping. It’s thin and plush for your baby to sleep and wiggle around on yet won’t wake them up mid-snooze by those irritating crinkle-noises.
Understanding customer needs, this crib pad features a significant sized skirt, making it easy to secure around your baby’s mattress, fitting snug and smooth. Additionally, it can endure repeated washings without compromising quality.
Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad – Best Organic
HIGHLIGHTS:
- Certified organic cotton
- Made in US
- Easy to clean
This 100% organic cotton waterproof crib pad is made of top-quality organic cotton, making it an excellent choice when looking for soft, breathable material for your little angel to snuggle up to at night. Due to the fabric’s quality, it offers a comfortable waterproof barrier that doesn’t easily sweat when compared to other fabrics.
Opting for an organic material means you can rest easy knowing there aren’t any additional harmful chemicals added to this product, letting your child inhale what they’re snoozing on without worry. Organic cotton is a healthier alternative when compared to other synthetic fabrics. Additionally, it protects from pests like allergens and dust mites as well.
Naturepedic’s mattress pad is machine washable letting you toss it into the washing machine and dryer after an accident and not worry about compromising the quality of the product. It’s created in a GOTS certified facility as well, meaning it’s made with quality organic materials without chemicals.
GRT – Best Overall Value
HIGHLIGHTS:
- Machine washable and dryer friendly
- 90-day full refund
- 9 inches thick
- 4-layer design
GRT’s 100-percent waterproof mattress pad for cribs is our selection for ‘Best Overall Value.’ You have the option to purchase either a single pad or a two-pack at an appealing price point, adding to this product’s overall value.
The mattress pad is constructed with a 4-layer design that includes a soft and breathable terry fabric cover and a durable base layer. In total, the product is nine inches thick.
Parents of babies keep plenty busy taking care of their little one, so it helps to have products that provide extra convenience to save time and energy. The GRT pad is also machine washable and dryer friendly so that cleaning can be stress-free.
Why we picked it
- The company offers customers a 90-day trial period. This allows you plenty of time to test out this item, and if it doesn’t meet your needs, you can receive a full refund.
Dry Defender – Best Hypoallergenic
This beautiful quilted waterproof pad is hypoallergenic and comfy enough to sleep on. It’s made of all non-toxic organic material, is unbleached, and made from soft cotton on which your tot can snooze soundly.
Created with a quilted design to offer a firm yet fluffy surface, your little one will be cozy warm with this breathable organic topper that’s plush and comfortable. It’s sleek, easy to put on, and its design also lets you take it off your mattress and put it back on without a struggle, letting you focus on more important tasks like feeding your munchkin in the wee hours of the morning.
The Dry Defender has a unique four-layer design to offer the utmost protection, and it’s inner polyester fill layer increases absorbency. The company guarantees zero liquid penetration that is 100% waterproof, letting you sleep easy knowing your tyke and mattress are both protected.
Crib Mattress Cover Buyer’s Guide
About Waterproof Crib Mattress Pads
A waterproof crib pad is an ideal product for anyone raising a small baby. Since tykes are always spilling and having accidents, keeping a waterproof pad on your crib prevents liquids from seeping through to your bedding. They protect from mold, mildew, and other harmful substances that could degrade your mattress quickly.
Additionally, they can absorb faster than other materials, wicking away liquids and keeping your babe dry through the night. Buying the right product can save parents from inconvenience, letting them easily toss the product in the wash for reuse throughout their baby’s childhood.
Types Of Crib Mattress Pads
With a wide variety of crib mattress pads to choose from, knowing which to select can feel like a never-ending research project. Here we’ll break down the essentials to make it easy.
Fitted pads
It’s essential to find a pad with a snug fit. Buying a bedding pad that’s not fitted correctly can leave you with a product that gapes at the ends, causing uncomfortable wrinkles and excess material that your munchkin can get caught in. Additionally, buying one that’s too small will have you wrestling to get it over your mattress.
Lie-flat pads
Crib pads that lie flat will often be more comfortable than the alternatives. Some pads create frustrating wrinkles and bulges, reducing the comfort of the material for your child. Rolling over uncomfortable material in the night could have your tot, and you, waking up in the middle of the night, undoing the benefits of a good bedtime routine.
Small pads
You can also opt to buy a small pad that simply fits the portion your child is sleeping on. While not always a great option long-term, it can be convenient as these types might save you from struggling to pull the edges of a pad down over your mattress every time, a common gripe of fitted sheets. Keep in mind if these aren’t secured they could pose a suffocation risk for your baby and should only be used when you can directly supervise your little one.
What To Consider When Buying A Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad
There are a few different aspects to keep in mind when thinking about what you want in a child’s bedding pad. We discuss a few so you can select the perfect product.
Organic vs Non-Organic
Deciding whether to go for an organic product or non-organic will depend on what’s important to you in a product for your child. Many people prefer to spend a bit extra to avoid potentially harmful chemicals. However, in some people’s experience, they grew up just fine without organic products and may not find them essential, or worth the extra cost.
Safety Regulations
Finding a pad that’s approved by a reputable organization can provide peace of mind for parents, in knowing their little one is resting safely.
GOTS
The GOTS organization (Global Organic Textile Standard) ensures that its certified products are produced with organic materials. Additionally, they procure them from farming systems that maintain and renew the soil fertility without utilizing pesticides or toxic fertilizers. The creation of their products also certifies quality animal use without genetic modification.
GREENGUARD
GREENGUARD helps buyers find quality products and helps manufacturers make quality goods. The company is part of Underwriters Laboratories, a global safety science leader that provides services, insights, and expertise to solve business challenges. They help customers attain sustainability, quality, and safety goals. GREENGUARD creates products with low chemical emissions to improve air quality in your home.
Softness
You want to make sure your little one is comfy but not stuck in a mattress that’s too soft for their bodies. The product needs to be firm enough to support your munchkin as they lie flat on their backs in their swaddle, but soft enough that it doesn’t make crinkle noises and wake them up in the middle of the night.
Care and Maintenance
It’s a good idea to find a waterproof mattress pad that can wash easily in a washing machine. Opting for a delicate pad might wind up being more of an inconvenience, and you might not want to be reading detailed washing instructions juggling a baby on your hip.
The Grip
Finding a crib pad with a good grip and fit is critical so it doesn’t slip around and cause unnecessary noises or uncomfortable wrinkles. Buying one that’s too big can leave gaps and bunching, and one that is too small might have you wrestling to get it back on after each washing.
The Cost
Fortunately, crib pads have all different sorts of price points, running anywhere from $15 to $100 and upwards. Great products don’t have to strain your bank account; however, keep in mind this is a product you’ll be investing in and using daily for a significant amount of time.
Easy to Put On and Take Off
Reading reviews and testing the bedding pads when you take it home to see how easily it slips on and off the mattress is a good idea. Struggling to pull an extra snug pad over your cushion after each wash will surely get tiring, so finding a perfect fit is key.
Benefits of Using a Waterproof Crib Mattress Cover
There are many benefits to consider when looking for a waterproof pad, and you’ll likely be thankful you went with something with this additional waterproof perk.
Keeps the Baby Dry While Sleeping
Most waterproof pads have a special sort of liquid wicking material that quickly absorbs. If your little one has an accident that leaks through their diapers in the middle of the night and doesn’t wake as a result, they won’t be left to sleep while sopping wet.
Provides Comfortable Sleeping
While some older waterproof crib mattress pad models could be loud, uncomfortable, and crinkly, many today offer significant comfort with a thicker top material. Some common materials used in quality products include cotton, wool, polyester, or a combination of these.
Protection Against Environmental Irritants
As your tot is still growing and developing their immune system, it’s wise to have a mattress pad that protects against mites, dust, and other irritants. When they’re young, they can be particularly sensitive to things like pollen or other allergens, making it challenging for them to get quality shut-eye.
Airflow Regulation
Since babies can easily get hot in cribs, having a waterproof pad that promotes airflow is critical for maintaining a comfortable environment and preventing excessive sweating. Bamboo and cotton are especially good for keeping cool at night and can help maintain a comfortable temperature for your little one.
Clean-Up Time Is Minimized
Since many waterproof pads can easily be tossed into a washing machine (as long as they’re washing machine friendly) they make for considerably easy clean-up, which can be a huge help while bouncing a small child around. Small things like being able to throw a product in the wash can make a significant impact with a baby in tow.
Conclusion
Having children can be messy, which makes purchasing the most efficient baby products that work for you that much more critical when juggling life with your munchkin. Small improvements like a machine-washable mattress pad or a product that doesn’t easily wear out can save you precious time when looking for replacement products down the line.
With our breakdown of top waterproof crib mattress pads, we hope you’re feeling well equipped to pick the best product for your preferences and lifestyle so you can keep your little babe snuggly warm and dry night after night. If you’re on the hunt for more products, we have additional resources that will be sure to help guide you.
Melanie Kassel
Performance Editor
About Author
As Sleep Advisor’s Performance Editor, Melanie writes and edits content throughout the site to ensure it’s accurate, engaging, and up-to-date.
Combination Sleeper